• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Link
  • Home
  • Membership
    • Member Dashboard
    • Expeditionist Only
    • Change Password
    • Forgot Password?
    • Support Us
    • Pick A Membership
  • Store
    • AZBackroads Store
    • Cart
    • Subscriptions
    • Hats
    • Hoodie
    • Wall Art
    • Downloads
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Connect With Us
    • Report A Trash Dump
    • AZBCE Ambassadors
    • Our Allies
  • The Backcountry
    • Arizona 4×4 Routes
    • Wildfires & Restrictions
    • Forest Alerts
    • The Guide to camping
    • Trail Etiquette
    • Arizona state trust land permit

Bureau of Land Management Road Closures | How it all started

Posted By

Kevin Allard

November 26, 2022

Posted in

BLM

Prior to the 1970s, motorized public land users mainly consisted of Motorcycles, Jeeps, snowmobiles, minibikes, go-carts, and Volkswagons. At this time, public land users were granted the fundamental right to construct “highways” under Section 8 of the Mining Act of 1866, otherwise known as Revised Statute 2477. Motorized users could travel across virgin soil, in any direction they pleased, to construct highways over public lands that were not reserved for public use. As a result, most of the roads we use to explore public lands today were created.

This practice persisted from 1866 until February 8th, 1972 when then-president Richard Nixon issued Executive Order 11644 to quell what the administration called “Unregulated Off-Highway Vehicle use.” The Executive Order demands federal agencies regulate cross-country travel and establish a “system of areas and trails” designated as open, closed, or limited to “off-road vehicle” use. The Executive Order, to this day, furnishes the only legal definition of “off-road vehicle” as “any motorized vehicle designed for or capable of cross-country travel on or immediately over land, water, sand, snow, ice, marsh, swampland, or other natural terrain.”

In response to Executive order 11644, the US Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management established agency regulations regarding the governance of cross-country travel on public lands. They each developed policy to designate geographical areas where motorized users are allowed to travel cross country with certain exemptions.

In 1976, the Mining Act of 1866 was repealed by the Federal Land Policy Management Act which Is known as the Bureau’s charter and multiple-use mandate that emphasizes retaining federal ownership of public land. Although the Mining Act was repealed, the Act makes the Bureau’s actions subject to all valid existing rights. Including Revised Statute 2477 rights of way.

“Nothing in this Act, or in any amendment made by this Act, shall be construed as terminating any valid lease, permit, patent, right-of-way, or other land use right or authorization existing on the date of approval of this act.”

FLPMA 701(a), 43 U.S.C. 1701 note (a).

“All actions by the Secretary concerned under this Act shall be subject to valid existing rights.”

FLPMA 701(h), 43 U.S.C. 1701 note (h).

“Nothing in this title shall have the effect of terminating any right-of-way or right-of-use heretofore issued, granted, or permitted.”

FLPMA 509(a), 43 U.S.C. 1769(a).

The next year, executive order 11644 was amended by Executive Order 11989 from president Jimmy Carter to include Section 9. Section 9 directs the agency head to immediately close trails and areas to the type of offroad vehicle they determine causes or will cause “considerable adverse effects on the soil, vegetation, wildlife, wildlife habitat or cultural or historic resources of particular areas.”

In general, federal land management agencies designated geographical areas in one of three categories as described below.

Open: The BLM designates areas as “open” for intensive ORV use where there are no compelling resource protection needs, user conflicts, or public safety issues to warrant limiting cross-country travel.

Limited: The agency designates areas as “limited” where it must restrict ORV use in order to meet specific resource management objectives. These limitations may include: restricting the number or types of vehicles; limiting the time or season of use; permitted or licensed use only; limiting use to existing roads and trails; and limiting use to designated roads and trails. The BLM may place other limitations, as necessary, to protect resources, particularly in areas that motorized OHV enthusiasts use intensely or where they participate in competitive events.

Closed: The BLM designates areas as “closed” if closure to all vehicular use is necessary to protect resources, ensure visitor safety, or reduce use conflicts

National Management Strategy for Motorized Off-Highway Vehicle Use on Public Lands

By the year 1999, thousands of miles of road were closed on a case-by-case basis with a vast majority of public lands closed or limited to cross-country travel. At the time OHV designations consisted of 94,958,435 acres of public land open to cross-country travel; 10,570,171 acres closed; 126,276,664 acres limited; and 26,441,557 acres Undesignated.

Managing the movement of people on public lands

This is when the federal government’s attempt to manage the movement of people on public lands started to take hold. As you can imagine, Executive Order 11644 was a massive change to the traditions practiced by generations of public land users. It has taken decades to make this transition and convince motorized users to stay on existing roads.

Driving off established roads is frowned upon by most of the 4×4 and motorized user community. Because of this sentiment, motorized users, especially the older crowd, believe that closures are the result of individuals violating this principle.

During the rule-making process for implementing the provisions of Executive Order 11644 as amended, anti-access groups wanted the Bureau to restrict Off-Highway Vehicles to designated roads. The Bureau of Land Management asserted Executive Order 11644 never intended to limit motorized use of roads and explicitly rejected the idea referring to it as “more restrictive.”

“There were many suggestions to establish criteria that would confine off-road vehicles to designated roads and trails. Executive Order 11644 provides for the designation of “areas and trails” rather than the more restrictive “roads and trails” … Numerous comments wanted the regulations to control hunting, firearms and registration as they relate to off-road vehicles. These are activities in which the States have traditionally established standards of control, and there is no intent to interfere in this function. Standards of control in these regulations have been limited to situations where the States either have no controls, or their controls may be considered insufficient for off-road vehicle activities on public lands.”

44FR 34834 June 15, 1979

In response to the Government and Performance and Results Act of 1993, the Bureau of Land Management later released its 2000-2005 strategic plan that made OHV regulations a top priority for the Bureau. Under long-term goal 1.1.3 of the plan, the Bureau asserts, “the increased use of off-highway vehicles (OHVs) is leading to a crisis situation in some areas. Many public lands are either undesignated or open for OHV use.“

Simultaneously, in the year 2000, the Bureau developed the National Management Strategy for Motorized Off-Highway Vehicle Use on Public Lands and the National Mountain Bicycling Strategic Action Plan in 2001. To this day, you can find the Management Strategy referenced in the Bureau of Land Management employee policy 1626 manual as a technical reference to managing OHV issues. The Management Strategy is also used by the US Forest Service, National Park Service, and Bureau of Reclamation, and is even referenced by the US Forest Service while consulting with land management planning in foreign nations.

In 2003, the Bureau of Land Management released its Priorities for Recreation and Visitor Services where the Bureau officially made Travel Management Planning a long-term priority. In the new commitment to the public, the Bureau pledged to transform the management of public lands away from the “traditional activity-based approach to management.”

From this point forward, the governance of roads on public land significantly changed. It no longer matters how seriously public land users take good stewardship and etiquette.

The Travel Management Process will be conducted even if every public land user follows every federal regulation and administrative decision.

“It is important to note that this strategy is indicative of a distinct shift from a traditional activity-based approach to management, to managing for specific individual, social and economic benefits.”

Part three of the plan lists BLMs priorities. Goal number one is to, “Improve Access to Appropriate Recreation Opportunities on Department of the Interior (DOI) Managed or Partnered Lands and Waters” with the objective to “establish a comprehensive approach to travel planning and management.”

Under part three, goal one, objective one, the Bureau lists five milestones, each containing multiple actions to achieve its goals.

Milestone 1: Address comprehensive travel management through the land-use planning process and through statutorily required planning efforts to improve access and recreation opportunities and experiences.

Milestone 2: Improve on-the-ground travel management operations and maintenance programs to sustain and enhance recreation opportunities and experiences, visitor access and safety, and resource conservation.

Milestone 3: Improve signing, mapping, and travel information and education for BLM public lands visitors.

Milestone 4: Implement comprehensive travel management through national strategies for motorized, mechanized, and non-motorized recreation.

Milestone 5: Expand and pursue partnerships, sources of funding, and guidance for transportation and travel management.

BLM Priorities for Recreation and Visitor Services

In response to this, the Bureau revised federal regulations in 2002 implementing the Travel Management Rule. This new revision repealed multiple provisions in Title 43 Part 8340 referencing the historical grant issued under the Mining Act of 1865. These provisions specifically recognized the road as a property right of the state while applying state law.

Amendments

Bureau of Land Management regulations concerning Executive Order 11644 can be found in Title 43 Part 8340 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Multiple subparts of Part 8340 have been amended over the years. As a result, the original intent of Executive Order 11644 has been butchered by the Bureau.

YearChanges
1979Original Rule established by Executive Order 11644.
1980Giving states jurisdiction over licensing requirements to operate an OHV.
1988Revises the regulations in 43 CFR Part 8340 to clarify some definitions used in the existing regulations and simplify the designation process.
2002Implements regulations concerning Recreation Use Permits, special events, and uses. This section also repealed provisions protecting RS 2477.
2020Implemented provisions concerning e-bikes and removed the term “cross-country” from the definition of off-road vehicle.

Policy Manuals

These Policy Manuals direct Bureau employees while carrying out the Travel Management process. In these manuals, you will notice the application of RS 2477 and state law when governing roads on public lands.

Policy Manual
1626Travel and Transportation Management Manual
2870Grant Administration
2809Special Considerations to Manuals 2801- 2807
2801Rights-of-way – General

Read Title 43 Part 8340 as amended.

Below, you can read the Code of Federal Regulations concerning the Bureau’s Travel Management Policy.


It’s no longer the 1970s

The Bureau’s attempt to control travel on public lands has been ongoing for over 50 years and has morphed from regulations made at the local level, into a blanket regulation for all public lands from coast to coast.

It’s important for local clubs and motorized use advocates to remember that it’s now 2022. Land use is governed differently and the leadership in our community cannot use the same tactics to keep roads open. Although necessary, education alone is not sufficient enough to secure the motorized use of our public lands in the face of ever-changing policies.

Kevin Allard [#facebook#]
Author: Kevin Allard

Kevin is an American outdoorsman born and raised in rural Arizona who grew up exploring the Arizona backcountry with his father. Today, he and his son travel to the most remote regions of Arizona, scavenging for the remains of early western pioneers. As a lifelong outdoorsman, Kevin has learned to stick close to his roots while engaging in important advocacy work regarding motorized access to public lands. You can find his work in many local and nationwide publications, including The Western Journal, 4Low Magazine, and his website AZBackroads.com.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Tags:

Arizona, Road Closure, Travel Management

You may also like…

  • RANGEfire! | Rural communities rise up against “green” energy projects

  • Protect The Harvest | How the ASPCA Shortchanges Animals and Donors

  • ShareTrails | Film Permit Requirements for National Park Service

  • RANGEfire! | Was the January 6th Committee formed to cover up what really happened?

  • RANGEfire! | What happens when wealthy urban environmentalists move to pretty Western cow towns?

  • Protect The Harvest | Growing Concerns of Farmland Purchases by China

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 × 2 =

Visit the AZBackroads.com Store

  • AZBackroads.com Ladies
    AZBackroads.com Ladies
  • No Biden 2024
    No Biden 2024
  • Adventure is not a crime Flex Fit Hat
    Adventure is not a crime Flex Fit Hat
  • AZBackroads.com T Shirt
    AZBackroads.com T Shirt
AZBackroads.com Store

Please Become A Member

We need your help to keep our backroads open. Please join today!

Join Now

Please Become an AZBackroads.com Member

As a member, you unlock access to:

  1. An incredible collection of GPS tracks.
  2. A collection of over 1,300 Points Of Interest.
  3. Commentary from the author, free merch, and a discount on all products in our store.
Learn More!

Welcome

Log In
Sign Up

Accepting

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Gab
  • About Us
  • Connect With Us
  • Report A Trash Dump
  • AZBCE Ambassadors
  • Our Allies
  • Take Action Now
  • Privacy & Return Policy

The Backcountry

  • Help Save Apache Trail
  • Arizona 4×4 Routes
  • Wildfires & Restrictions
  • Mapping Adventure
  • Forest Alerts
  • THE Guide to Camping
  • Trail Etiquette
  • AZ State Trust Land Permit

Membership

  • Member Dashboard
  • Members Only
  • View Profile
  • Edit Profile
  • Change Password
  • Log out
  • Support Us

Store

  • AZBackroads Store
  • Membership
  • Hat
  • Shirt
  • Hoodie
  • Wall Art
  • Download
  • Cart

This website is built and maintained by Kevin Allard. All content on this website is protected by Copyright and shall not be redistributed without written permission by the author. The Arizona Backcountry Explorers and AZBackroads.com name and logos are registered trademarks of Kevin Allard. Names and logos of our partners, affiliates, and syndicates are registered trademarks of their respective owners.