• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Link
  • Home
  • Membership
    • Member Dashboard
    • Expeditionist Only
    • Change Password
    • Forgot Password?
    • Support Us
    • Pick A Membership
  • Store
    • AZBackroads Store
    • Cart
    • Subscriptions
    • Hats
    • Hoodie
    • Wall Art
    • Downloads
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Connect With Us
    • Report A Trash Dump
    • AZBCE Ambassadors
    • Our Allies
  • The Backcountry
    • Arizona 4×4 Routes
    • Wildfires & Restrictions
    • Forest Alerts
    • The Guide to camping
    • Trail Etiquette
    • Arizona state trust land permit

Road closures | Arizona courts or federal bureaucrats

Posted By

Kevin Allard

February 23, 2020

Posted in

BLM, Land Use, USFS

Congressional nullification opens the door for Arizona courts to decide on road closures

Nullifying The USDA Forest Service Travel Management Rule 36 CFR 212 will open the door for an Arizona court of competent jurisdiction to close roads over Federal public lands. Local control could be the best chance we have to keep motorized access open.

We all know that there are legitimate reasons to close some roads over the public domain. Anybody who spends time in the backcountry knows some people have a complete disregard for the beauty of nature. When you visit the backcountry, you notice roads going everywhere. Many of them are not protected by law, but instead, are permitted by the federal government. While others are protected under law, post-1976 roads are subject to closure by federal land management agencies.

In 1976 the Federal Land Management Policy Act (FLPMA) was signed into law. This law grandfather in every single road in existence at the time. Before 1976, roads were granted under the Mining Act of 1865 and were considered RS 2477 Rights of Way. However, All roads created from that point on were permitted by the federal government and can be closed.

It’s important to consider how the offroad community grew over the past several years. I know for a fact, a lot of roads were created between 1976 and now. Studying topo maps from the USGS, it’s clear that many RS 2477 Right of Way are ignored during travel management planning.

Ignoring the law

Aside from the constitutional concerns, administrative procedure violations, and congressional representation, we encounter an ignorance of RS 2477. When questioned about RS 2477 roads, our federal land managers say the burden of proof is our responsibility. I strongly disagree. The federal law that acknowledges RS 2477 roads is the same law that enables the state to claim the rights to RS 2477 roads.

Representative Mark Finchem proposed legislation to claim all RS 2477 roads over federal land. The bill was passed and became ARS 37 931. The Arizona law clearly says only a “court of competent jurisdiction” can close a road that pre-dates the existence of the FLPMA. The law also acknowledges the state’s right to widen and pave the road or build highways, regardless of condition.

Special AZBCE discount | 10% off orders $500 or more at 4wheel Parts

Timeline of the off-road community

In 1976 the off-road community was tiny. It primarily consisted of full-size four-wheel-drive vehicles, Jeeps, and motorcycles. Since 1976 the off-road community has grown exponentially. The unfortunate result is the formulation of more and more roads. As discussed above, these roads do not fall under RS2477.

In the 1980s, the ATC and ATV were released to the market. From this point on, the most inexperienced riders could obtain a trail-ready machine for under $3,000. Between the 1980s and today, the offroad community encountered massive growth. The once small, tight-knit community of Jeep, Bronco, Scout, and motorcycle enthusiasts became the minority.

Now, here we are in 2020 with a whole new machine on the market. The side by side, or better known as the UTV, was single-handedly the most impressive increase the off-road industry has ever seen. In Arizona, UTV’s make up an estimated 43% of our community and has a massive influence on policymaking, economic impact, and public perception.

Exclusive AZBCE deals | online guns and ammo ORDER NOW

Conclusion

Between 1976 and today, many new roads have been created as a result of better access to our public lands. These roads should be managed according to law. As mentioned above, if laws, acts, and statues already allow the closure of roads, especially roads built after 1976, why would we allow even more bureaucratic rules and regulations?

The bottom line is, the Travel Management Rule 36 CFR 212 took existing travel management laws, acts, and statutes to the next level. The Obama era rule, supercharged the already existing laws, acts, and statutes that were put in place in the 1970s. The travel management rule took decision making away from the Forest Service, the people of Arizona, our elected officials, state agencies, and local organizations such as the Tonto Recreation Alliance.

Decision making is granted to out of state environmental groups. Environmental groups now do the studies, make the recommendations, and give us our alternatives. This is not how the founding fathers intended it. The laws the federal bureaucracy are violating, are meant to protect rural America, our community, and the people who shoulder the consequence.

These laws acts and statutes were enacted by the dually elected men and women who represent the people. Our community leaders, state representatives, and courts should have the final say when closing any roads within state lines. Congressional Nullification of 36 CFR 212 will put the power of government in the hands of the people. Exactly what the founding fathers intended.

Kevin Allard [#facebook#]
Author: Kevin Allard

Kevin is an American outdoorsman born and raised in rural Arizona who grew up exploring the Arizona backcountry with his father. Today, he and his son travel to the most remote regions of Arizona, scavenging for the remains of early western pioneers. As a lifelong outdoorsman, Kevin has learned to stick close to his roots while engaging in important advocacy work regarding motorized access to public lands. You can find his work in many local and nationwide publications, including The Western Journal, 4Low Magazine, and his website AZBackroads.com.

34.0489281-111.0937311

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Tags:

You may also like…

  • Protect The Harvest | Conservative Group Hires Animal Rights Operative

  • ShareTrails | Stop the Sale of Sand Mountain!

  • American Stewards | Environmental Groups Lobby Congress to Double ESA Budget and Increase Consultations on Private Lands

  • American Stewards | Local Citizens and a City Council Defeat China

  • American Stewards | Policies to Roll Back 30×30 Presented to Western Caucus

  • RANGEfire! | Recurring Nightmare: WOTUS attacks on private property continue

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

7 + 2 =

Visit the AZBackroads.com Store

  • AZBackroads.com Ladies
    AZBackroads.com Ladies
  • No Biden 2024
    No Biden 2024
  • Adventure is not a crime Flex Fit Hat
    Adventure is not a crime Flex Fit Hat
  • AZBackroads.com T Shirt
    AZBackroads.com T Shirt
AZBackroads.com Store

Please Become A Member

We need your help to keep our backroads open. Please join today!

Join Now

Please become an AZBackroads.com Member

As a member, you unlock access to:

  1. an incredible collection of GPS tracks.
  2. a collection of over 1,300 Points Of Interest.
  3. and commentary from the author, free merch, and a discount on all products in our store.

We Need Your Help

Learn More

Welcome

Log In
Sign Up

Accepting

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Gab
  • About Us
  • Connect With Us
  • Report A Trash Dump
  • AZBCE Ambassadors
  • Our Allies
  • Take Action Now
  • Privacy & Return Policy

The Backcountry

  • Help Save Apache Trail
  • Arizona 4×4 Routes
  • Wildfires & Restrictions
  • Mapping Adventure
  • Forest Alerts
  • THE Guide to Camping
  • Trail Etiquette
  • AZ State Trust Land Permit

Membership

  • Member Dashboard
  • Members Only
  • View Profile
  • Edit Profile
  • Change Password
  • Log out
  • Support Us

Store

  • AZBackroads Store
  • Membership
  • Hat
  • Shirt
  • Hoodie
  • Wall Art
  • Download
  • Cart

This website is built and maintained by Kevin Allard. All content on this website is protected by Copyright and shall not be redistributed without written permission by the author. The Arizona Backcountry Explorers and AZBackroads.com name and logos are registered trademarks of Kevin Allard. Names and logos of our partners, affiliates, and syndicates are registered trademarks of their respective owners.